
Motor Control Center overload protection must let an MCC motor start while still responding to harmful sustained current.
The trip class describes a relay's time-current behaviour under defined conditions.
Select it using the motor's starting duty and thermal limits, rather than the class number alone.
What an Overload Trip Class Actually Means
An overload relay, also called a motor overload relay, responds to excessive current over time. Its trip class helps describe how quickly that protection operates.
Manufacturers also use the term tripping class for this characteristic. A higher class generally permits longer operation at the relevant high-current test condition.
However, Class 20 does not mean the relay always trips after twenty seconds. Actual trip time depends on current, thermal state, and the selected relay's characteristic.
For European projects, EN IEC 60947-4-1 provides the relevant framework for electromechanical motor starters and overload relays. Use the manufacturer's applicable curves alongside the class marking.
Thermal relay classes commonly include 10A, 10, 20, and 30. Electronic products may also identify classes with an E suffix and different time bands.
Do not treat every product with a similar class number as having the same curve. Review the actual device and its stated test conditions.

Six Steps for Selecting the Right Trip Class
Confirm the Motor Current and Relay Position
Start with the motor nameplate and the manufacturer's protection guidance. Identify its full-load current, commonly shortened to FLC, at the intended supply conditions.
Next, identify the relay's sensing position in the circuit. A line-mounted relay and an inside-delta relay do not measure the same current.
Follow the approved starter diagram and device instructions when setting the relay. Do not copy a current setting from another wiring arrangement.
Record the Actual Starting Duty
Obtain the motor's expected starting current and acceleration time. Starting current, also called start current in this context, changes as the motor accelerates.
Use a starting profile where possible rather than a single current estimate. The connected load and available supply can affect how long acceleration takes.
Consider the most demanding permitted operating condition. A lightly loaded commissioning start may not represent the motor's normal production duty.
Compare the Start Profile with the Relay Curve
Plot or review the starting profile against the relay's time-current characteristic. The relay must accommodate the intended start without unnecessary tripping.
Use the manufacturer's tolerance information when assessing the margin. Avoid selecting a class from the class number and acceleration time alone.
For example, a start lasting several seconds does not automatically require the matching numerical class. The current multiple and thermal condition also matter.
Check the Motor's Thermal Limits
A relay that tolerates a long start still needs to protect the motor. Compare its response with the motor's permitted heating and stall limits.
Obtain cold and hot safe-stall information where the motor supplier provides it. A stalled motor can heat differently from a motor accelerating normally.
Select a slower class only when the motor's thermal capability permits it. Extending the delay cannot make an unsuitable starting duty acceptable.
Assess Hot Restarts and Repeated Starts
A cold motor and a recently loaded motor do not begin with the same thermal margin. The relay may also retain thermal information.
Check both cold and hot characteristics for the selected device. A setting that accepts the first start may still trip during repeated operation.
Review allowed starts per hour and required cooling time. Use the motor and relay documentation rather than assuming every stopped motor has cooled fully.
Confirm Coordination and Commission the Selection
After choosing the trip class, confirm the complete starter combination. The selected overload relay must remain compatible with the required short-circuit coordination arrangement.
Record the device reference, class, current setting, and sensing arrangement. Then compare measured starting behaviour with the design assumptions during commissioning.
If the result differs, investigate before changing the protection. A mechanical problem or weak supply can extend acceleration without justifying a slower class.
Compare Common Classes Without Misreading the Numbers
The table below shows commonly published cold-state thermal relay bands at 7.2 times the current setting. It describes test conditions, not universal motor starting allowances.
Thermal relay class | Cold-state tripping band at 7.2 times setting current | Selection consideration |
|---|---|---|
Class 10A | More than 2 seconds, up to 10 seconds | Check shorter starting duties against the actual curve |
Class 10 | More than 4 seconds, up to 10 seconds | Review normal starting duty and required thermal protection |
Class 20 | More than 6 seconds, up to 20 seconds | Consider longer acceleration only within motor thermal limits |
Class 30 | More than 9 seconds, up to 30 seconds | Requires careful review of long-start and stall conditions |
Class 10A and Class 10 share the same upper value in this table. Their lower boundaries differ, so they are not identical characteristics.
Electronic Class 10E, 20E, and 30E can use different lower boundaries. Always confirm which class designation the selected product actually uses.
The test current is also important. A curve at six times setting current cannot be compared directly with a band at 7.2 times.
Some motor controllers use manufacturer-specific thermal model parameters. Read their definitions before treating a parameter value as a conventional trip class.
Note: A trip class defines behaviour at specified conditions, rather than a fixed delay for every overload or motor start.
Keep Current Setting Separate from Trip Class
The current setting and trip class solve different problems. The setting establishes the current reference, while the class describes time-current response.
Raising the current setting shifts how the relay interprets motor current. It can weaken protection if the new setting exceeds the approved motor protection basis.
Changing the tripping class also changes the permitted high-current duration. Therefore, neither adjustment should become a routine cure for an unexplained trip.
For direct-on-line circuits with line sensing, use the motor and relay instructions to establish the setting. Other arrangements need their own assessment.
Inside-delta sensing is one example where the measured current differs from motor line current. Follow the approved connection diagram rather than applying a universal multiplier.
An overload relay also does not replace the required short-circuit protective device. Confirm both overload protection and fault protection within the complete starter design.
Investigate Trips Before Selecting a Slower Class
A start-related trip can indicate a selection problem, but it can also reveal an abnormal operating condition. Record when the trip occurs before making changes.
Compare the affected start with a known acceptable operating profile. Look for changes in current, acceleration time, loading, or supply conditions.
A structured investigation checks the following items:
The motor nameplate matches the installed motor and supply.
The relay setting matches the actual sensing arrangement.
The driven machine moves freely and has the expected load.
The supply remains suitable throughout the starting period.
Phase currents and connections show no unexplained abnormality.
Recent starts and thermal memory explain the motor's initial condition.
Keep other protection functions in the review. Phase loss, current imbalance, or a separate stall function may explain the event.
Do not repeatedly reset and restart a motor without understanding the cause. Repeated unsuccessful starts can add heat and worsen the original problem.
If normal acceleration exceeds the permitted thermal window, review the starting system itself. A revised load condition or starting method may be necessary.
Give Giantele a Complete Motor Protection Brief
Provide the motor schedule, full-load current, and proposed starting method with your enquiry. Include the expected acceleration profile and available motor thermal information.
Also state whether the process needs frequent starts or hot restarts. These details help the supplier discuss the duty rather than choose from motor power alone.
Giantele offers power distribution equipment and technical support for project discussions. Ask for a feeder schedule identifying each relay and its proposed settings.
Request the supporting time-current curves and coordination references. The documentation should match the actual devices in the Motor Control Center proposal.
During commissioning, retain measured starting records and approved settings. These records help maintenance teams assess later changes without guessing the original selection basis.
Review the protection again if the motor, load, or starting method changes. An unchanged cabinet does not mean its original motor protection settings remain suitable.
Conclusion
Choose the trip class by comparing motor starting behaviour, relay curves, and the motor's thermal limits.
Check current settings, hot restarts, and starter coordination before approving the final protection arrangement.
Send Giantele your Motor Control Center motor schedule and request a documented overload protection selection.
FAQ
Q: Which trip class suits a Motor Control Center motor?
A: A Motor Control Center motor needs a trip class that accommodates its start while respecting thermal limits. Use the actual relay curves and motor data.
Q: Should every Motor Control Center use Class 20 relays?
A: A Motor Control Center should not use Class 20 by default. Select protection for each motor's starting profile, thermal capability, and required coordination.
Q: Does Class 10 mean exactly ten seconds for every overload?
A: Class 10 describes a defined trip class under specified conditions. Actual time varies with current, thermal state, and the selected overload relay's curve.
Q: Can I raise FLC settings to prevent start trips?
A: FLC information provides a basis for the approved current setting. Investigate start trips before changing that setting or selecting a slower tripping class.